Judicial Reform as Political Insurance
Argentina, Peru, and Mexico in the 1990s
Publication Year: 2008
Published by: University of Notre Dame Press
Contents and Acknowledgments
Download PDF (531.3 KB)
I thank the many people who inspired, assisted, and supported me while I was working on this project. The fi rst are my parents, Betty and Max, two people on whom I could always count. A big thank-you also goes to my brother, David, for believing in the value of my research, for editing my entire dissertation, ...
Introduction. Latin America and Judicial Reform: Why Would Politicians Enact Institutional Reforms That Appear to Limit Their Own Political Power?
Download PDF (746.9 KB)
Judicial reform, defined here as institutional changes claiming to increase the independence and authority of the judicial branch, swept Latin America in the 1990s. Argentina, Peru, and Mexico, for example, each engaged in constitutional revisions that appeared to empower their judiciaries. ...
Chapter One: Explaining Latin America’s Recent Judicial Reforms
Download PDF (738.3 KB)
This chapter presents two potential explanations for understanding the judicial reforms that swept Latin America in the 1990s. The first section outlines an argument based on the transition to a market economy and the pressures of international financial institutions (IFIs). First it provides an overview of the literature on ...
Chapter Two: Judicial Reform in Argentina in the 1990s
Download PDF (772.9 KB)
Argentina’s tumultuous twentieth-century political history has been marked by a weak and subservient judiciary that has traditionally served to uphold laws passed by illegitimate civil and military governments alike. Beset by chronic instability and repeated replacement, the Argentine Supreme Court has been unable to develop ...
Chapter Three: Judicial Reform in Peru in the 1990s
Download PDF (776.9 KB)
After twelve years of military rule, Peru returned to democracy in 1980 with free and fair elections. For the next ten years, the country was governed by the two traditional parties but neither proved capable of solving the problems of double-digit inflation, economic crisis, or internal terrorism that beset the country. ...
Chapter Four: Judicial Reform in Mexico in the 1990s
Download PDF (762.5 KB)
Immediately on taking office in December 1994, President Ernesto Zedillo delivered to the Mexican Congress a comprehensive judicial reform package of dramatic constitutional changes affecting the independence and authority of the judicial branch. The Supreme Court was granted the power of judicial review in specifically ...
Chapter Five: The Paradox of Latin America’s Judicial Reforms: Lessons Learned
Download PDF (551.9 KB)
On the surface, Latin America’s judicial reforms present a paradox: why would politicians enact institutional reforms that appear to limit their own political power? We can better answer this question by separating judicial reform into its two component stages, initiation and implementation. This book’s investigation of ...
Download PDF (611.3 KB)
Download PDF (583.4 KB)
Download PDF (548.2 KB)
Page Count: 168
Publication Year: 2008
Series Title: From the Helen Kellogg Institute for International Studies
Series Editor Byline: Scott Mainwaring, series editor