We cannot verify your location
Browse Book and Journal Content on Project MUSE

Carving Nature at Its Joints

Natural Kinds in Metaphysics and Science

Edited by Joseph Keim Campbell, Michael O'Rourke, and Matthew H. Slater

Publication Year: 2011

Reflections on the metaphysics and epistemology of classification from a distinguished group of philosophers.

Published by: The MIT Press

Series: Topics in Contemporary Philosophy

Title Page, Copyright Page

pdf iconDownload PDF (66.8 KB)

read more


pdf iconDownload PDF (52.0 KB)
pp. vii-viii

The contemporary problem of natural kinds is related to a long tradition of philosophical reflection, dating from at least as far back as Plato’s discussions of Forms. Natural kinds offer an answer to the question, what is it for an individual thing to belong to a certain kind of thing and thus to be of the same kind as other particular...

read more


pdf iconDownload PDF (34.0 KB)
pp. ix

Earlier versions of the essays in this volume were presented at the eleventh annual Inland Northwest Philosophy Conference (INPC), held March 15 – 17, 2008, in Pullman, Washington and Moscow, Idaho. For their financial and administrative support of the conference, we thank the philosophy departments at Washington State...

read more

1. Introduction: Lessons from the Scientific Butchery

pdf iconDownload PDF (141.8 KB)
pp. 1-31

Good chefs know the importance of maintaining sharp knives in the kitchen. What’s their secret? A well-worn Taoist allegory offers some advice. The king asks about his butcher’s impressive knife-work. “Ordinary butchers,” he replies “hack their way through the animal. Thus their knife always needs sharpening. My father...

read more

2. Induction, Samples, and Kinds

pdf iconDownload PDF (129.4 KB)
pp. 33-52

There are lots of ways of answering such questions. In “ induction,” the questions are answered by noting the relation between F and G in observed cases and making some sort of extrapolation or generalization. This is presumably done with the aid of background knowledge. But the approach taken is one in which the number...

read more

3. It Takes More Than All Kinds to Make a World

pdf iconDownload PDF (342.3 KB)
pp. 53-84

The various species of elementary particle (some of which are depicted below, in table 3.1) are in many ways ideal cases of natural kinds. Each elementary particle belongs to exactly one of these natural kinds and it essentially belongs to that kind. In terms of certain properties, there are perfect uniformities within each...

read more

4. Lange and Laws, Kinds, and Counterfactuals

pdf iconDownload PDF (112.7 KB)
pp. 85-96

In this essay I examine and question Marc Lange’s account of laws, and his claim in the preceding chapter that the law delineating the range of natural kinds of fundamental particle has a lesser grade of necessity than do laws connecting the fundamental properties of those kinds with their derived properties...

read more

5. Are Fundamental Laws Necessary or Contingent?

pdf iconDownload PDF (114.7 KB)
pp. 97-112

A central issue in metaphysics is whether there are any necessary relations in nature. The Humean answer is that there are not, so that laws of nature are contingent. The opposing view, that laws of nature are such necessary relations, offers a very different metaphysical picture of the universe. In this essay I primarily address a dispute...

read more

6. Para-Natural Kinds

pdf iconDownload PDF (259.3 KB)
pp. 113-127

There is a folk taxonomy for para-natural kinds. Scientists refine this taxonomy by improving the alignment of our commonsense categories with the corresponding para-natural kinds. After William Hershel discovered infrared light, physicists acquiesced to his talk of invisible shadows (despite the locution echoing the...

read more

7. Boundaries, Conventions, and Realism

pdf iconDownload PDF (188.4 KB)
pp. 129-153

If you have driven in Europe recently you may have had that strange feeling. You see a sign that says ‘Deutschland' or ‘France’ or ‘España’ — and just drive through. No customs barrier, no passport control — just a sign. You say “Ah!” and carry on; the sign could be a hundred yards further out and it would make no difference. Yet by crossing...

read more

8. Natural Kinds and Biological Realisms

pdf iconDownload PDF (103.1 KB)
pp. 155-173

There are a number of “realism” issues in biology, issues about what “exists,” what is “real,” what is “objective.” In general, realism issues tend to be confused and the biological ones are no exception. We shall see that the interesting realism issues in biology are best seen as ones over which kinds “carve nature at its...

read more

9. Three Ways of Resisting Essentialism about Natural Kinds

pdf iconDownload PDF (109.4 KB)
pp. 175-197

Essentialism about natural kinds has three tenets. The first tenet is that all and only members of a natural kind have some essential properties. The second tenet is that these essential properties play a causal role. The third tenet is that they are explanatorily relevant. I examine the prospects of questioning these tenets and point out...

read more

10. Arthritis and Nature’s Joints

pdf iconDownload PDF (159.9 KB)
pp. 199-230

It should come as a surprise to almost no-one that the thought that diseases constitute natural kinds does not generally sit well with the essentialist picture of natural kinds as championed by Kripke and Putnam in the 1970s. According to that essentialist picture, in order for a class of entities to be a natural kind it is required...

read more

11. Predicting Populations by Modeling Individuals

pdf iconDownload PDF (425.6 KB)
pp. 231-251

Despite their many differences, the so-called dynamic and statistical interpretations of evolutionary theory (ET) share a common understanding of that theory. ET is, among other things, a theory about how frequencies of types change in populations, and these changes are recorded as changes in the values of variables measured...

read more

12. Similarity and Species Concepts

pdf iconDownload PDF (242.1 KB)
pp. 253-288

Conceptions of species that are explicitly based on similarity or resemblance between group members have fallen out of widespread favor despite the apparent importance of morphological criteria of identification for field biologists. To put the matter succinctly: similarity, be it morphological or genotypic, is widely regarded as insufficient...

read more

13. Species Concepts and Natural Goodness

pdf iconDownload PDF (106.0 KB)
pp. 289-311

Philippa Foot (2001) has defended a form of natural goodness evaluation in which living things are evaluated by how well fitted they are for flourishing as members of their species, in ways characteristic of their species. She has argued, further, that assessments of moral goodness (virtue and vice) in humans are...

read more

14. How to Think about the Free Will/Determinism Problem

pdf iconDownload PDF (138.8 KB)
pp. 313-340

Common sense says that we have free will. We make choices. And while we are sometimes in a position where we make a choice while being mistaken about what our options are, this is not always, or even usually, the case. Ordinarily, when we make a choice we really do have the choice we think we have. You can stop reading this...


pdf iconDownload PDF (33.0 KB)
pp. 341


pdf iconDownload PDF (83.1 KB)
pp. 343-355

E-ISBN-13: 9780262298780
Print-ISBN-13: 9780262516266

Page Count: 368
Publication Year: 2011

Series Title: Topics in Contemporary Philosophy