Nursing, Physician Control, and the Medical Monopoly
Historical Perspectives on Gendered Inequality in Roles, Rights, and Range of Practice
Publication Year: 2001
Published by: Indiana University Press
Download PDF (34.3 KB)
Download PDF (50.4 KB)
Fundingassistanc e for manuscript preparation has been provided by the Omicron Chapter of Sigma Theta Tau (Syracuse University College of Nursing), the Syracuse University Senate Research Committee, the Syracuse University Small Grants Program, and Syracuse University Office of Research. ...
Download PDF (123.0 KB)
Over the past three decades, significant changes have occurred in the nursing profession and in the conventional societal definitions of women and their roles. As the women’s movement reemerged in the late 1960s and many women refused to uphold the traditional roles allocated to them, a parallel trend in nursing ...
Nursing, Physician Control, and the Medical Monopoly: An Overview
Download PDF (91.2 KB)
Organized nursing and medicine are currently on a collision course, with the American Nurses’ Association (ANA) often taking positions on nurses’ roles, rights, and range of practice in opposition to those espoused by the American Medical Association (AMA). The strained relations in the last few decades have a very long history, ...
PART I. “Exposing the Meretricious Lies”: Early Women Healers and Nurses and the Mythology of Medicine’s “Natural” Supremacy over Healing
Download PDF (15.8 KB)
1. “The Mere Trivia of History”? The Legacy of Early Women Healers and Physicians’ Efforts to Exclude or Control Them
Download PDF (179.7 KB)
In this chapter, sources on gender and nursing are brought together to make visible a centuries-old lineage of women healers and nurses and to document its relationship to that of physicians. Taking a longer view of women healers over several centuries helps us to understand whether nurses indeed usurped medical rights ...
2. “She Hath Done What She Could”: Reforming Nursing as Physicians Tighten the Medical Monopoly in Great Britain,1800s to the Early 1900s
Download PDF (193.2 KB)
Medical control over women’s healing activities in Europe, particularly in Great Britain increased during the eighteenth century, becoming a reality by the mid to late nineteenth century, despite the fact that university-educated physicians were a distinct minority among health-care practitioners. ...
3. The Search for American Nursing Origins: Differing Approaches to the History of Nursing and the Medical Monopoly in the United States,1800s to the Early 1900s
Download PDF (150.4 KB)
The extent to which the long history of women healers and the experiences of European, particularly British, nurses, have influenced the development of American nursing and nurse-physician relations has not been studied in depth. Instead, a number of American researchers have focused on nurses in a women’s world, ...
PART II. The Purposeful Move toward Dominance: Subordinating Nurses and Achieving a Medical Monopoly
Download PDF (15.6 KB)
4. “For Their Own Good”: Physicians Manipulating, Trivializing, and Coercing Nurses, Later 1800s to the 1920s
Download PDF (207.2 KB)
This chapter focuses on the continued efforts by physicians in the United States to achieve a monopoly in health care in the mid to late nineteenth century and into the first two decades of the twentieth century. From previous chapters, it is clear that physicians over several centuries were determined to create a gendered monopoly, ...
5. “The Exclusive Guardians of All Matters of Health”: The Consolidation of Medical Monopoly in the 1920s and 1930s
Download PDF (145.1 KB)
By 1920 the Western world had been through a terrible war, in which close to 550,000 Americans were killed, including 300 nurses who had served overseas. World War I not only claimed a horrible toll in human life, it also served as a catalyst to swell the ranks of qualified graduate nurses. ...
6. A Growing Unease: Nurse-Physician Interprofessional Relations from the 1940s to the 1960s
Download PDF (148.3 KB)
With the entrance of the United States into the Second World War, the prestige of physicians and the power of organized medicine were substantially reinforced. Following the war, the rapidly expanding knowledge in the basic sciences; the widespread use of sulfa, penicillin, and eventually antibiotic drugs; ...
7. Reconciling Practice with Protest and Confrontation with Cooperation: Nurse-Physician Relations in the 1970s
Download PDF (315.8 KB)
By the 1970s the medical monopoly had been strongly buttressed by the rapid expansion of knowledge from the physical and biological sciences and by increased technological capacities.The health-care industry had become the third largest in the nation; indeed, there was an 80 percent increase in the number of health workers ...
PART III. An Outdated, Burdensome Model of Monopolistic Control: Entering the Twenty-First Century with a Fractured Health-Care System and Continuing Medical Opposition to Nurses’ Autonomy
Download PDF (15.9 KB)
8. Who Needs the Autonomous Professional Nurse? Gender Stereotypes Remain Central to Nurse-Physician Relations
Download PDF (238.9 KB)
By the 1980s the backlash against the reemergent feminist movement was very apparent in the return to a more conservative political agenda. We begin this chapter with the resurrection of the traditional stereotype of the nurse as mother surrogate, brought back to life to reduce the widespread dissatisfaction ...
9. Challenges to the Medical Monopoly: Nurses’ Gains in Direct Payment, Hospital Privileges, Prescriptive Authority, and Expanded Practice Laws
Download PDF (336.6 KB)
By the 1980s it was possible for nurses to attack the medical monopoly directly. Following the U.S. Federal Trade Commission’s ruling in 1975 that antitrust laws also applied to professional workers in the health-care system, unfair laws and practices affecting nurses could now be legally challenged. ...
10. The Results of the Medical Monopoly: “A Regulatory and Policy-Making Quagmire”
Download PDF (373.2 KB)
By the end of the twentieth century, the results of the centuries-old medical monopoly were singularly unimpressive. In this chapter, focused on the last decade of the twentieth century, we consider nurses’ and consumers’ critiques of the health-care “system,” discuss the efforts at reform by nurses, ...
Download PDF (173.4 KB)
Download PDF (72.4 KB)
Page Count: 560
Illustrations: 1 index
Publication Year: 2001