The Fight to Save the Redwoods
A History of the Environmental Reform, 1917–1978
Publication Year: 1983
"This is not a simple or ordinary history of a conservation crusade. Schrepfer very ably traces the changes in scientific wisdom from nineteenth-century romanticism and teleological evolutionism to more current ecological dynamism—and the influence of those intellectual developments on political history. . . . The subject is important—much broader than the title suggests—and so is the book."—American Historical Review
Published by: University of Wisconsin Press
List of Illustrations
List of Maps
Perhaps sensing an old vulnerability in the "forests of the night," twentieth-century man shivers in the misty recesses of the redwoods. These are ancient trees, some as much as two thousand years old and towering over 350 feet. The armies of trees that J. R. R. Tolkien marched across the hills of Middle-earth ...
During the years spent working on this manuscript, both in California and the East, I accumulated debts requiring acknowledgment. Many of those active in environmental issues and the redwood controversy gave invaluable information, helped sharpen my analysis, and criticized the manuscript. ...
1. Progressives and Scenic Preservation
On an August afternoon in 1917, three men drove north from San Francisco in search of "a forest wall reported to have mystery and charm unique among living works of creation." Madison Grant, Henry Fairfield Osborn, and John Campbell Merriam left from the Russian River in Sonoma County to camp in the northern redwoods, made accessible that year by a new highway. ...
2. Citizen Reform: California's State Park System
In the summer of 1919, in response to accelerated western logging and the concern of the Save-the-Redwoods League, Congress passed a resolution directing the secretary of the Interior to investigate the advisability of a redwood national park.1 A year later the secretary recommended a park along Del Norte County's lower Klamath River, ...
3. Ideology of Reform: A Natural Theology
In deciding to save the redwoods, the league was building upon almost a century of western science. As early as the 1830s, imprints of leaves and cones very similar to California's redwoods had been found in prehistoric sedimentary rocks of Europe and North America.1 ...
4. Parks: Recreation or Englightenment
In March, 1938, the Save-the-Redwoods League rejected a National Park Service proposal for a redwood national park. The superlative Mill Creek trees targeted by the service were threatened with logging, and the league was searching for funds to save them. Yet the directors asked the federal government to defer to the state's efforts to acquire the stand.1 ...
5. Progressive Opposition to the New Deal: 1930-1949
There are obvious continuities between the reforms of the progressive period and the New Deal, yet most of those who had considered themselves progressives and who lived into the 1930s opposed Franklin Delano Roosevelt.1 The men of the league were no exception. Their 1938 vote against a redwood national park reflected differences over park administration, ...
6. Evolution and Ecology
Prior to World War II, the Save-the-Redwoods League and the Sierra Club were allies. They shared common goals and a common philosophy, based in part upon the influence of evolutionary assumptions. During the 1930s and 1940s, the natural sciences made dramatic advances. ...
7. The Roots of Militancy: 1950-1964
IN A 1959 letter attacking a proposed freeway, David R. Brower, appointed executive director of the Sierra Club seven years earlier, quoted physicist J. A. Rush: "When man obliterates wilderness, he repudiates the evolutionary force that put him on his planet. In a deeply terrifying sense, man is on his own."1 The statement typifies the union of philosophical naturalism and citizen activism that emerged out of the 1950s. ...
8. The Redwood National Park: 1965-1968
There were three stages in what became one of the major conservation battles of the 1960s-the fight to establish the Redwood National Park. The first was from the National Park Service's 1964 report until January, 1966, when it became obvious the club had failed to prevent the Johnson Administration from abandoning the service's Redwood Creek proposal in favor of the league's more modest plan. ...
9. David Brower and the Sierra Club: 1964-1970
In 1968 the Sierra Club was at a height in its militancy, growth, and influence. At its urging, the second session of the Eighty-ninth Congress established the Redwood and Cascades national parks, expanded four wilderness areas, defeated three dams, and founded the scenic rivers, estuaries, and national trails systems. This power owed much to decades of accumulated support, political expertise, and anger. ...
10. The Battle Rejoined: 1969-1977
Few political compromises have wrought a more untenable situation than the Redwood National Park Act, which devoted one narrow river valley to both clearcutting and wilderness recreation. The moment the park bill was signed in 1968, Arcata Redwood, Simpson Timber, and Georgia-Pacific began cutting their remaining old growth in the Redwood Creek watershed. ...
11. A Second Redwood National Park Act: 1977-1978
During the last year of the battle over park expansion, the loggers of northern California staged mass demonstrations and evoked the power of the national AFL-CIO. The timber companies denied clearcutting damaged the park, called its expansion a "land grab," and prophesied economic doom for the North Coast. ...
12. No Place to Stand: Saving the Redwoods, 1917-1978
The progressive years of the early part of this century are unique in the attention they garnered from historians in the 1950s and 1960s. As sons discovering the clay feet of their fathers, these generally liberal historians found the progressives weak in their commitment to social change. ...
Bibliography of Unpublished Sources
Publication Year: 1983
OCLC Number: 550500161
MUSE Marc Record: Download for The Fight to Save the Redwoods