Poverty of the Imagination
Nineteenth Century Russian Literature about the Poor
Publication Year: 2001
Published by: Northwestern University Press
The writing of this book taught me what it means to be indebted, by which I mean, in a manner not unlike that of Pushkin’s improvisor, to discover in my own work themes and viewpoints others have imparted to me over the years. Above all I owe thanks to Hugh McLean for having faith in me long before I did myself, for letting me potter about in the sloppy and, at times it seemed, purely fictitious workshop of my ideas, and finally for his friendship....
Introduction: Poverty and Imagination
Russian literature boasts a long and varied tradition of works about or including the poor, and its history is yet to be written. This is not that book. The present work proposes instead something at once more modest and more ambitious: to explore what might be called the poetics of the perception of poverty.1 To approach poverty as a cultural construction, the initial...
Chapter One. Expelled from the Garden of Poverty: Sympathy and Literacy in “Poor Liza”
KARAMZIN’S “POOR LIZA” tells a story simple enough on the surface. A poor peasant girl is taken advantage of by a rich aristocrat. Seduced and abandoned, Liza drowns herself. What complicates Karamzin’s text, however, is the question of literacy. On one hand, “Poor Liza” can be read as casting the blame for the tragedy on the hero’s...
Chapter Two. The Call of Poverty: Learning to Love the Low in “Egyptian Nights”
THE NARRATIVE OF “POOR LIZA” provided Russian culture with what proved to be an exceptionally durable model for conceiving and portraying interactions between the poor and the nonpoor— a model far more lasting, it should be noted, than the story’s wild but then fleeting popularity. An important countermodel, however, is given by Pushkin’s...
Chapter Three. The Meaning of Poverty: Gogol’s Petersburg Tales
IN THIS CHAPTER we turn to Gogol’s Petersburg tales, five stories about the downtrodden and impoverished in Russia’s daunting and cruel metropolis.1 In the last 100 years, the tales’ fame has rested on their absurd violations of narrative and logical propriety, but at the same time they address a number of serious topics, most prominently poverty...
Chapter Four. Gogol against Sympathy
GOGOL CONTINUED TO WRESTLE with the ambiguity of poverty even after his career as an artist came to an end. In “Poor Liza” and “Egyptian Nights” we have seen two projects of uniting with the poor on grounds of sympathy, projects with their own motives, their unique successes and, perhaps more strikingly, failures. Yet for all the...
Chapter Five. “The Poverty of Our Literature”
THE TEXTS WE HAVE SEEN thus far, though not numerous, exemplify a much broader pattern found across an array of works by a variety of authors. In Russian writing from Karamzin on, poverty serves as a broad (and undoubtedly not always conscious) metaphor for Russia’s perceived cultural position vis-à-vis Europe, regularly spawning, in...
Chapter Six. By His Poverty: Dostoevsky and the Imitations of Christ
AS PUSHKIN READ his Karamzin attentively, so Dostoevsky digested his Gogol with great seriousness. It has long been a cornerstone of Dostoevsky studies that the writer began his career by reacting against, or parodying, his forebear.1 That the national preoccupation with poverty and imagination stands at the heart of their dispute, however, is not...
Conclusion: The Wealth of the Russian Imagination
THE TRADITION CATALOGUED HERE finds Russian authors writing about penury within a cultural and figural framework inherited from Karamzin. The writers in question begin from shared assumptions, but quickly diverge as they begin to weave their own narratives. This continuous return to and resistance against a common center meanwhile...
Page Count: 282
Publication Year: 2001
Series Title: Studies in Russian Literature and Theory
Series Editor Byline: Gary Saul Morson See more Books in this Series
MUSE Marc Record: Download for Poverty of the Imagination