Passing of Postmodernism, The
A Spectroanalysis of the Contemporary
Publication Year: 2010
Published by: State University of New York Press
CHAPTER ONE: The Phantom Project Returning: The Passing (On) of the Still Incomplete Project of Modernity
“Let’s just say it: it’s over” (Politics 166). Postmodernism, that is. Or so Linda Hutcheon claims. For Hutcheon, “the postmodern moment has passed, even if its discursive strategies and its ideological critique continue to live on—as do those of modernism—in our contemporary twenty-first century world” (Politics 181, my emphasis). Hutcheon’s announcement rings—and I imagine this is her intention—like a death knell, the final word. Indeed, the entire epilogue to the second edition...
Ruptures and Specters
Employed loosely in Arnold Toynbee’s multivolume Study of History (eight volumes of which were published between 1934 and 1954), the term “postmodern,” written “post-Modern,” was used to describe a late-nineteenth-century epochal shift: the end of a “modern” bourgeois ruling class and the growing dominance of an industrial working class. I do not wish to get lost in the early history of the term, but Toynbee’s initial theorizing of a “post-Modern” period of Western...
Exorcisms Without End
In Specters of Marx, Derrida argues that Marxism was haunted by various spirits. According to Derrida, one of these spirits cannot be ignored; it cannot be ignored because it compels movement—that is, critical, aesthetic and/or revolutionary movement. But a spirit, Derrida insists, arrives, or manifests, as a ghost, a specter. It is both seen and unseen, present and absent; or, if we employ Derrida’s earlier terminology, the spirits of Marxism exist only as trace and differance. What is interesting...
The (Phantom) Project Still Incomplete
With the theory of the specter and of mystification in mind, I would like to return now to the above “survey” of the postmodern debate via a discussion of one of postmodernism’s staunchest, and most influential, critics: Jürgen Habermas. For Habermas, postmodernism is a type of interruption, an interruption of what he refers to as the still incomplete project of modernism. Since the late 1960s, Habermas argues, the “spirit of aesthetic modernity has . . . begun to age”...
CHAPTER TWO: Spectral Circumventions (of the Specter): Poststructuralism, Derrida, and the Project Renewed
Poststructuralism and/as Postmodernism
Although many critics view poststructuralism and thus deconstruction as a distinctly postmodern and/or nihilistic form of theoretical discourse, commentators who wish to situate it in a much broader philosophical tradition typically reaffi rm poststructuralism as a distinctly French discourse, a discourse that is not entirely sympathetic to the pragmatism of (American) postmodernism. Pointing to the (albeit, latent) remainders of phenomenology and structuralism within...
Private Irony All the Way Down?
For most detractors of postmodernism, particularly Christopher Norris, Richard Rorty (along with Stanley Fish and Jean Baudrillard) is the epitome of all that is wrong with the past fifty or so years of theoretical discourse. A self-styled “postmodern bourgeois liberal,” Rorty champions hard-line American neo-pragmatism, insisting that the possibility of truth claims and/or meaningful political intervention has long...
The Force of Derrida’s Indecision
Following Caputo, it would be (in)accurate to say that Derrida is an atheist.31 Of course, such a statement—it is (in)accurate to say that Derrida is an atheist—is probably misleading; or rather, it doesn’t seem to lead anywhere. Whether or not Derrida believes in God is hardly addressed; because of the parenthetical prefix, this statement fails to embrace fully a particular position. It is not decisive in the sense that...
CHAPTER THREE: Writing of the Ghost (Again): The Failure of Postmodern Metafi ction and the Narrative of Renewalism
Neither Logocentric nor Logo Centric
In the preface to The Tetherballs of Bougainville, Mark Leyner reminds us that “When an astronomer observes a galaxy in some distant realm of the universe, . . . [h]e is quite literally looking at the past” (9). This is, of course, as Leyner goes on to point out, an effect of light; by the time the light of a distant galaxy reaches us, here on Earth and in the “present,” the galaxy itself “may no longer even exist” (9). So, Leyner...
From an Ethics of Perversity to an Ethics of Indecision
In his extended discussion of David Lynch’s Lost Highway, Žižek argues that “the art of the ridiculous sublime,” as exemplified in Lynch’s films, is neither a “cold postmodern exercise” nor a “New Age” affirmation of “a subconscious Life Energy” uniting all events and experiences. Highlighting the fact that Lynch is associated with both positions—that is, some view him as “the ultimate deconstructionist ironist” while others...
Metafiction’s Failure and the Rise of Neo-Realism
If we were to wager on it—wager, that is, on the exact moment when the “passing” of postmodernism became undeniably imminent—1989 would be, as I suggested in chapter 2, a fairly safe bet. Following a writer like Raymond Federman, we might in fact argue that the first symptoms of some terminal epistemological illness became...
The Project of Renewalism
In Charlie Kaufman and Spike Jonze’s film, Adaptation—their followup to the particularly solipsistic Being John Malkovich—Kaufman writes himself into his adaptation of Susan Orlean’s book, The Orchid Thief. Played by Nicolas Cage, Kaufman accidentally becomes the main character of the film, a film that is supposed to be about Susan Orlean (played by Meryl Streep). In a manner that makes Vonnegut’s presence...
A Conclusion . . . Perhaps
One final example. In Toni Morrison’s Beloved, the concept of the specter— of the ghost, of the repressed—is pivotal. For this reason, Beloved can help us to clarify two distinct yet intimately related concepts. On one hand, the text exemplifies a distinctly renewalist aesthetic; its narrative strategies overtly endorse and embrace the ironic spectrality of the mimetic promise. On the other hand, Beloved, like Hamlet, offers us a very specific model of the specter, a model that speaks to the...
Page Count: 210
Publication Year: 2010
Series Title: SUNY series in Postmodern Culture
Series Editor Byline: Joseph Natoli See more Books in this Series
MUSE Marc Record: Download for Passing of Postmodernism, The