Masculinity and the Hollywood Detective Film
Publication Year: 2006
Published by: State University of New York Press
Title and Copyright Pages
C O N T E N T S
I L L U S T R A T I O N S
A C K N O W L E D G M E N T S
Part I. The Crime Lab: Theorizing Masculinity and the Detective Genre
1. Introduction: The Case
From William Powell to Humphrey Bogart—or debonair to tough; from Bruce Willis to William Petersen—or wisecracking to wise: the celluloid detective has evolved over time, processing society’s fears about crime and articulating debates about law enforcement and justice. The 1980s saw cinematic justice exacted by muscle and firepower;...
2. The Myths of Masculinity
Feminist critics have tended to regard the category of masculinity as a monolithic, stable, unproblematic, and hegemonic idea, against which the representations of women have been measured. For example, Laura Mulvey in her seminal 1975 essay “Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema” argues that there is only one dominant type of subjectivity in narrative film and that...
Part II. Investigating Masculinity: The 1940s and the 1980s
3. Investigating National Heroes:British Sleuths and American Dicks
In a response to the social changes incited by World War II, Hollywood offered audiences two different types of detective-hero in the 1940s: the soft-boiled transitional detective and the hardboiled noir-detective.1 The 1950s also produced two different responses to the Cold War: the conservative cop of the police procedural and the corrupt cop of what have been identified as...
4. Investigating Crisis: Neo-Noir Heroes and Femmes Fatales
Hollywood film has a history of negotiating masculinity through the denial of cinematic voice and space to women. As Susan Faludi notes, in the 1950s Hollywood film offered fewer emancipated women than they had in the 1930s and 1940s, and fewer films concerned with women in general (Backlash 143–44). ...
5. Investigating Crisis: The Spectacle of “Musculinity”
The 1980s witnessed the return to noir aesthetics and themes, but parallel to this trend was that of the action film, and its popularity affected the detective genre, with a proliferation of the cop action hero. The cop action film offered a hybridization of the detective and action film by having a detective as protagonist who investigates a crime, with an emphasis on spectacular action as...
Part III. Investigating The Crime Scene: The 1990s and 2000s
6. Investigating the Hero: The Criminalist
The 1980s were dominated by a processing of masculine crisis and a backlash against feminist empowerment in films like the neo-noir and the cop action film. But the early 1990s experienced a shift to “sensitive men,” which was mirrored in the detective film by the appearance of protagonists who were...
7. Investigating the “Other”: Race and the Detective
The first detective film with a black protagonist was R. W. Phillips’s 1918 film A Black Sherlock Holmes (Langman and Finn, Silent xv). Although the black detective may have appeared early in the history of the detective genre, this single film is an anomaly, and the black detective as a prevalent character would not emerge for another fifty years, when Sidney Poitier...
8. Investigating the “Other”: Women and Youth
The early 1990s saw the introduction of kinder, gentler men on screen, mirroring a social shift to the valuing of more sensitive and vulnerable masculinity. But this move away from the hypermasculine action hero also included the proliferation of feminine or “feminized” heroes: women and youths. ...
9. Investigating the “Other”: The Cult of Villainy
Hollywood has always constructed villains for its heroes to fight, but the villain has rarely received the critical attention that the hero has. Yet without the opposition of villainy there could be no concept of heroism. ...
10. End of the Investigation: Case Closed
The detective genre has had a long history on the big screen, appearing almost as soon as the medium was born and becoming popular in the sound era as its many characters, complicated plots, suspense, and intrigue were developed. Each decade has seen the dominance and proliferation of at least one trend in the genre: the classical sleuth and softboiled detective in the...
N O T E S
S E L E C T E D F I L M O G R A P H Y
W O R K S C I T E D
Page Count: 356
Illustrations: 26 b/w photographs
Publication Year: 2006
Series Title: SUNY series, Cultural Studies in Cinema/Video (discontinued)
Series Editor Byline: Wheeler Winston Dixon See more Books in this Series
MUSE Marc Record: Download for Detecting Men