We cannot verify your location
Browse Book and Journal Content on Project MUSE

How Did Davy Die? And Why Do We Care So Much?

Dan Kilgore and James E. Crisp

Publication Year: 2010

Just over thirty years ago, Dan Kilgore ignited a controversy with his presidential address to the Texas State Historical Association and its subsequent publication in book form, How Did Davy Die? After the 1975 release of the first-ever English translation of eyewitness accounts by Mexican army officer José Enrique de la Peña, Kilgore had the audacity to state publicly that historical sources suggested Davy Crockett did not die on the ramparts of the Alamo, swinging the shattered remains of his rifle "Old Betsy." Rather, Kilgore asserted, Mexican forces took Crockett captive and then executed him on Santa Anna's order. Soon after the publication of How Did Davy Die?, the London Daily Mail associated Kilgore with "the murder of a myth;" he became the subject of articles in Texas Monthly and the Wall Street Journal; and some who considered his historical argument an affront to a treasured American icon delivered personal insults and threats of violence. Now, in this enlarged, commemorative edition, James E. Crisp, a professional historian and a participant in the debates over the De la Peña diary, reconsiders the heated disputation surrounding How Did Davy Die? and poses the intriguing follow-up question, “. . . And Why Do We Care So Much?”  Crisp reviews the origins and subsequent impact of Kilgore’s book, both on the historical hullabaloo and on the author. Along the way, he provides fascinating insights into methods of historical inquiry and the use—or non-use—of original source materials when seeking the truth of events that happened in past centuries. He further examines two aspects of the debate that Kilgore shied away from: the place and function of myth in culture, and the racial overtones of some of the responses to Kilgore’s work.

Published by: Texas A&M University Press


pdf iconDownload PDF

Title Page, Copyright Page

pdf iconDownload PDF

read more


pdf iconDownload PDF

p. 5

THIS ESSAY originated as the presidential address to the Texas State Historical Association on March 4, 1977. Many friends assisted in searching for the sources used in the original paper and in this expanded and...

read more

How Did Davy Die?

pdf iconDownload PDF

pp. 9-50

THE GOOD LORD generously endowed David Crockett with those qualities the backwoods required: rugged strength, unusual perseverance, extraordinary courage, and fierce determination. Crockett capitalized on...

read more

Dan Kilgore and His Big Little Book

pdf iconDownload PDF

pp. 51-104

“Looking at Dan Kilgore’s slender volume,” mused Archie Mc- Donald from his editor’s desk in Nacogdoches, “ . . . you wonder How Did Dan Stir Up Such a Mess?”1 It’s hard to take at face value Kilgore’s protestations that he had no intention of stirring...

. . . And Why Do We Care So Much?

pdf iconDownload PDF

pp. 104-120

E-ISBN-13: 9781603443470
E-ISBN-10: 1603443479
Print-ISBN-13: 9781603441940
Print-ISBN-10: 1603441948

Page Count: 120
Illustrations: 2 line art.
Publication Year: 2010

Edition: Enlarged, Commemorative Edition

OCLC Number: 680622482
MUSE Marc Record: Download for How Did Davy Die? And Why Do We Care So Much?

Research Areas


UPCC logo

Subject Headings

  • Alamo (San Antonio, Tex.) -- Siege, 1836.
  • Crockett, Davy, 1786-1836.
  • Kilgore, Dan, 1921-1995. How did Davy die?.
  • Kilgore, Dan, 1921-1995 -- Influence.
  • Texas -- Historiography.
  • Crockett, Davy, 1786-1836 -- Death and burial.
  • You have access to this content
  • Free sample
  • Open Access
  • Restricted Access