Motherhood and Infertility in Ireland
Presence of Absence
Publication Year: 2013
Published by: Cork University Press
Title Page, Copyright, Dedication
It is a daunting task to try to adequately acknowledge all the people who provided support and inspiration for the work that has resulted in this book. I apologise if I have failed to mention people who were instrumental in the project or its vision in some way. ...
Introduction: Conceiving the Presence of Absence
The presence of absence explains the paradox, the sensation and the life experiences of infertility in Ireland. There are few experiences in life more culturally contingent than conceiving and giving birth. Deeply embedded in the meanings of family, gender, community and nation, the politics associated with conception, ...
1. Famine’s Traces: Hunger for Motherhood, Family, Fertility
In her evocative poem called ‘The Famine Road’, Eavan Boland draws poignant connections between history and the presence of absence, comparing the Famine Road with infertility. Here the woman’s sense of self worth and her concept of her own body as valueless space or a project with no purpose are deeply marked with the history of loss, ...
2. Motherhood Contested: Re-thinking the Woman/Mother Paradigm in Ireland
In the post-Celtic Tiger moment of the early twenty-first century, Ireland seemed caught between a lament for tradition and the embrace of social change. In fact, what everyone wanted to talk about was change imagined through the conceptual frame called tradition – a reference that marks the present more distinctly than the past. ...
3. Conceiving Nonconformity: Challenging Hetero-normative Meanings of (in)Fertility
Many of the stories above have explored how women see their own journeys towards motherhood as part of a resistance to the institutional operations of power that have shaped the meaning of motherhood in a number of ways. Through these stories women speak about the agency with which they harness the meanings of reproduction, ...
4. Conceiving of Grieving
Mary O’Donnell’s words above convey not only a sense of emptiness but the cyclical nature of grief that comes with the body’s betrayal each time there is a failure to conceive. The last two chapters located the meanings of conception and motherhood within particular normative contexts in Ireland, ...
5. Eggs, Sperm and Conceptions of a Moral Nature
Infertility treatment has provoked a re-examination of the role of procreation in shaping the meanings of gender, sexuality, kinship and family. At the same time infertility confronts the role of nature in sexual, moral, biological and technological conception. This is not unique to the Irish social and cultural context but is part of the local moral world. ...
6. Conceptions of Contention: Donor Challenge to the Dimensions of Relatedness
Conventional definitions of parenthood often employ biology in order to naturalise ethical and moral assumptions implicit in social relationships. Eggs and sperm are important symbols in the construct of nature and parenthood as they are the biological building blocks of both offspring and relationships. ...
7. Embryos and the Ethics of Ambivalence
As I spoke to people about their experiences with assisted reproduction, and IVF in particular, one of the most complicated issues that arose was how to decide the fate of embryos that are created in the process. Because IVF often results in more embryos than can safely be returned to a woman’s body, there is now a possibility of ‘supernumerary’ or surplus embryos. ...
8. Conclusion: Confirmation and Contestation in a Changing Ireland
‘Oh but Ireland has changed . . .’ I heard this refrain about change from virtually everyone I spoke with in the course of eighteen months of fieldwork. People were referring generally to the way the rapid economic development known as the ‘Celtic Tiger’ had facilitated new employment opportunities and an improved lifestyle for many Irish families. ...
In a story about change and continuity in Ireland’s approach to motherhood, choice and procreation, there have been many events that both serve as and hearken to touchstones marking time and history. Two such events took place as this book was going to press. ...
Notes and References
Publication Year: 2013
MUSE Marc Record: Download for Motherhood and Infertility in Ireland