Feminist Interpretations of John Rawls
Publication Year: 2013
Published by: Penn State University Press
Series: Re-Reading the Canon
Title Page, Copyright Page
Table of Contents
Take into your hands any history of philosophy text. You will fi nd compiled therein the “classics” of modern philosophy. Since these texts are often designed for use in undergraduate classes, the editor is likely to offer an introduction in which the reader is informed that these selections represent the perennial questions of philosophy. The student is to assume that ...
List of Abbreviations
Introduction: Biography of a Bibliography: Three Decades of Feminist Response to Rawls
By providing a chronological overview of English-language feminist engagements with Rawls from A Theory of Justice (TJ) onward,1 this “biography of a bibliography” displays the range of issues canvassed by feminist readers of Rawls as well as their wide disagreement about the value of his corpus for feminist purposes. As we shall see, feminist responses to Rawls’s ...
Chapter 1: Radical Liberals, Reasonable Feminists: Reason, Power, and Objectivity in MacKinnon and Rawls
As the introduction to this volume shows, John Rawls’s turn, if that is what it was, to political liberalism from the comprehensive liberalism of TJ was not generally greeted as a welcome turn of events by many feminists. According to the standard interpretation, Rawls, buffeted by the criticisms of communitarians and conservative religious attacks on liberalism, ...
Chapter 2: Feminism, Method, and Rawlsian Abstraction
As indicated in the introduction to this volume, Rawls has been enormously infl uential in contemporary political philosophy, and his ideas and methods continue to shape philosophical debates about justice, liberty, equality, autonomy, and democracy. Given the centrality of Rawlsian concepts to these debates, feminist political theorists must consider how and ...
Chapter 3: Rereading Rawls on Self-Respect: Feminism, Family Law, and the Social Bases of Self-Respect
In TJ, Rawls famously wrote that self-respect is “perhaps the most important primary good” (440). Indeed, he adduced its primacy to defend his theory of justice in a number of places. But as subsequent discussion has shown, he was imprecise in defi ning “self-respect,” using the term interchangeably with “self-esteem.” Moreover, he failed to examine systematically ...
Chapter 4: “The Family as a Basic Institution: ”A Feminist Analysis of the Basic Structure as Subject
In Section 50 of JFR, titled “The Family as a Basic Institution,” Rawls replies to Okin’s feminist critique of TJ. He states, “If we say the gender system includes whatever social arrangements adversely affect the equal basic liberties and opportunities of women, as well of those of their children as future citizens, then surely that system is subject to critique by the ...
Chapter 5: Rawls, Freedom, and Disability: A Feminist Rereading (Nancy J. Hirschmann)
When political theorists and philosophers take up the question of disability, they generally do so with regard to questions of justice: allocation of resources to disabled people (whether directly through accommodation, subsidy, or health care, or indirectly, say, through scientifi c research); distribution of resources (which disabilities or illnesses should receive more dollars, ...
Chapter 6: Rawls on International Justice
In Frontiers of Justice: Disability, Nationality, Species Membership (2006), Martha Nussbaum advances a feminist critique of Rawls’s theory of international justice. While she identifi es herself as a student of Rawls and dedicates the book to his memory, Nussbaum seeks to show the insuffi ciency of his theory of international justice, particularly as found in his LP, when it ...
Chapter 7: Jean Hampton’s Reworking of Rawls: Is “Feminist Contractarianism” Useful for Feminism?
In this chapter, I look at Jean Hampton’s “feminist contractarianism” to explore what she means by the term “contractarian” and to evaluate the extent to which her work can provide resources for feminism. I start by considering Hampton’s proposed contract in order to draw out some critical distinctions between her Kantianism and that of Rawls. Crucially, ...
Chapter 8: Liberal Feminism: Comprehensive and Political
As we have seen in the introduction to this volume, in PL Rawls argues for a turn in political philosophy from conceiving liberalism as a comprehensive moral doctrine to conceiving it as a public political philosophy. This refl ects the conviction that coercive state action is justifi ed—when constitutional essentials and basic justice are at stake—only if supported by ...
List of Contributors
Page Count: 200
Publication Year: 2013
Series Title: Re-Reading the Canon
Series Editor Byline: Nancy Tuana, General Editor See more Books in this Series
MUSE Marc Record: Download for Feminist Interpretations of John Rawls