Theodicy, Eschatology, and the Biblical Sources of Moby Dick
Publication Year: 2012
Published by: Northern Illinois University Press
Title Page, Copyright
In this study I seek to examine Moby-Dick in the context of the author’s dramatization of the problem of evil, a subject of recurrent interest in Western culture and Judeo-Christian tradition. Framing Melville’s fictional exploration of this vexed question was his immersion in the Bible, especially the text of the Old Testament ...
1—Joban Theodicy and Apocalyptic Eschatology
A little over a century ago, in a discussion of “The Sick Soul” in his Varieties of Religious Experience (1902), the philosopher and psychologist William James examined a human personality type that, in contrast to what he had earlier called a proponent of the “religion of healthy-mindedness,” or a type that minimized the existence of evil in the world, ...
2—Pilgrimage and Prophecy
In the previous chapter, we have reviewed the biblical paradigms of theodicy and eschatology that offered a potential rationale for the existence of evil and human suffering that Melville explored in Moby-Dick. Yet the novel also draws extensively on its immediate religious, historical, and cultural contexts. ...
3—Chaos Monster and Unholy Warrior
If the apocalyptic and eschatological themes of Moby-Dick are repeatedly invoked in the early chapters of the novel as Ishmael goes in search of a whaling vessel (as we have seen above), the Joban theme follows a more gradual pattern of development, being hinted at the start of the novel but made fully manifest only when Ahab makes his first appearance in chapter 28. ...
4—Cetology, Cosmology, Epistemology
In the previous chapter, we have explored the influence of Joban theodicy and apocalyptic eschatology on the characterizations of Ahab and the White Whale. As an anguished victim of divine malevolence like Job, Ahab has mythologized Moby Dick into a modern version of the archetypal Leviathan—becoming, in the process, an exemplar of both eloquent protest, like Job, ...
5—Comic and Tragic Variations
While questions of cetology, cosmology, and epistemology, as we have seen, inform a number of chapters within the cetological center of Ishmael’s narrative, the modes of comedy and tragedy, similarly imbued with biblical import, also help structure a number of scenes from the same extended middle portion of the narrative. ...
6—Hubris and Heroism, Mortality and Immortality
Whereas a mix of comic and tragic motifs informs the larger biblical themes within the middle third of Moby-Dick, the development of Ahab’s excessive pride, or hubris, appears in tandem with his distinctive traits of heroic courage in the final quarter of the narrative. ...
7—Combat and Catastrophe
In the previous chapter, we have seen how Ahab’s exemplary heroism blends with self-destructive hubris, while related questions of mortality and immortality raised by both Ahab and Ishmael in the last quarter of the novel contribute to the development of important religious and philosophical ideas. ...
At the start of his discussion of “How Religion in the United States Avails Itself of Democratic Tendencies” in Democracy in America, Alexis de Tocqueville noted the importance of having “fixed ideas” to support one’s religious beliefs and also the challenges that the power of private judgment, as fostered by democracy, could present to a properly ordered view of the universe: ...
Selected Bibliography of Melville and Moby-Dick Studies
Page Count: 384
Publication Year: 2012
OCLC Number: 868220378
MUSE Marc Record: Download for Inscrutable Malice