Hating Empire Properly
The Two Indies and the Limits of Enlightenment Anticolonialism
Publication Year: 2013
Published by: Fordham University Press
Title Page, Copyright
Prologue: Enlightenment, Colonialism, Modernity
Enlightenment, les lumières, Aufklärung: What does it mean to invoke this term, with its evident and often-examined root metaphor of light? Does placing it alongside colonialism immediately mark a turn to its inversion, a shift in metaphors from light to dark (for example, the “dark side” of the Enlightenment and similar variations on this ...
Introduction: Companies, Colonies, and Their Critics
Little could be further from the rage of an angry French philosophe or the moral gravitas of a British parliamentarian with a view to the judgment of history than the comic narcissism of Shakespeare’s Falstaff. In his efforts to woo two mistresses at once—a cheater to them both—he loses both. And yet, unlike Falstaff, many European countries did indeed trade at once, and very effectively, with two Indies, east and west. The...
Part I Denis Diderot: The Two Indies of the French Enlightenment
1 / Doux Commerce, Douce Colonisation: Consensual Colonialism in Diderot’s Thought
First the traveler, then the philosophe: this couplet is as important to the story of eighteenth-century intellectual history as is the revolutionary and the philosopher or the soldier and the statesman.1 As a variation on this I would also add the administrator and the philosophe as another vital pair of complementarities and antagonisms. This chapter considers...
2 /On the Use and Abuse of Anger for Life: Ressentiment and Revenge in the Histoire des deux Indes
Anger, hatred, revenge, ressentiment: this chapter begins a preliminary consideration of this set of closely related if distinct terms.1 Not, perhaps, a happy collation, but one important layer that recurs frequently in the thick and varied strata of the Histoire des deux Indes under the covered earth to which Diderot refers. To some it must serve as a bilious...
Part II Edmund Burke: Political Analogy and Enlightenment Critique
3 /Between France and India in 1790: Custom and Arithmetic Reason in a Country of Conquest
Let us cross over the English Channel and follow the current of popularity of the Histoire des deux Indes as it spread from France to one particular reader in Britain. This reader, already a noted member of Parliament and in the midst of his engagement with American affairs, found much to admire in that work. Indeed it may have aided him only...
4 /Jacobinism in India, Indianism in English Parliament: Fearing the Enlightenment and Colonial Modernity
Just what did Edmund Burke fear in the Jacobins of France, and what might that tell us about concurrent events taking place far off in colonial Bengal? Perhaps the question is better answered if we reverse it: Just what can colonial Bengal—or more broadly, events occurring at Britain’s mercantile colonial frontier—tell us about Burke’s fear of the emergence of...
5 /Atlantic Revolutions and Their Indian Echoes: The Place of the Americas in Burke’s Asia Writings
Of the two Atlantic revolutions that occurred between 1770 and 1800 in the New World, one is granted a large place by historical memory and is hailed by many in the period and after as possessing a world-historical significance: the American Revolution. The other, in the French sugar colony of St. Domingue, has until recently been pushed aside or actively ...
Epilogue. Hating Empire Properly: European Anticolonialism at Its Limit
What might C. L. R. James have meant by this passage, which makes the case—following a Hegelian model of consciousness, where it is the slave whose ability to grasp the concept of freedom exceeds that of his master—that the slogans of the revolution meant far more to the insurgent blacks of St. Domingue than to any Frenchman?1 If for Kant it was a...
Page Count: 320
Illustrations: 7 b/w illustrations
Publication Year: 2013
MUSE Marc Record: Download for Hating Empire Properly