The Politics of Faith during the Civil War
Publication Year: 2013
Published by: Louisiana State University Press
Title Page, Copyright Page
Political preachers were at the heart of the debate over the separation of church and state during the American Civil War.1 American ministers and laypeople alike held various opinions about clerics who preached on political topics. The war brought to the forefront a controversy that had grown up in the prewar North over whether ministers...
1. Preachers, Slavery, and Antebellum Politics
The generation of Americans that fought the Civil War inherited a political tradition that celebrated the separation of church and state. During the tumultuous years immediately preceding the war, certainly the largest part of American church leaders kept politics and religion distinct. And yet, between the end of the U.S.-Mexican War and the start of the Civil...
2. The Power and Place of the Wartime Northern Ministry
In short order after Fort Sumter, Americans recognized the magnitude of the war and the unprecedented peril in which their beloved Union now stood. As they looked to the clergy for guidance, more and more of them abandoned their concerns over political preaching and grew critical of all but the most expressly patriotic preachers. By their...
3. Partisanship and Potential Damage: Why Americans Feared “Disloyal” Preachers
In most cases, northern ministers supported the Union war effort and the Lincoln administration and worked doggedly to sustain the resolve of both citizens at home and soldiers in the field. Some clerics, however, spoke ill of the president and other political leaders or highlighted northern societal inequities in positing that the Union’s shortcomings might very well...
4. The Assault on Disloyalty in the Northern Ministry
Ministers understood better than most that the eyes and ears of the people were upon them. The bulk of preachers welcomed the public’s increased attention, thinking it necessary if the clergy was to lead the patriotic vanguard on the homefront. At times, however, popular and church inquiry revealed parsons who were unable or unwilling to meet their nationalistic obligations. When that happened, all kinds of forces arrayed...
5. What the Preachers Thought: Political Preachers in the North
It is clear that preachers who, for whatever reason, refused to figuratively wave the Union standard from behind their consecrated lecterns garnered widespread reproach. And yet, many ministers and their defenders persisted in avoiding partisan preaching. Clearly many intractable Union clerics resisted the politicization of their pulpit—and...
6. The Confederate Ministry
A central reality plagued the South’s brief foray into nation building: the Confederacy was not original unto itself. Most in Dixie identified with their fellow southerners in a fundamentally different way than they did Americans elsewhere. But even if most in the South believed themselves a separate people by 1861, that did not make it easy for them to abandon old loyalties. Just as the colonists’ declaration of...
7. Confederate and Unionist Religious Life under the Gun
During the civil war, ministers in the occupied South frequently found the expression of their loyalties unwelcome, often dangerous, and sometimes deadly. The presence of the Federal military, for instance, severely stifled the dulcet tones of Confederate religious leaders. In such places as Nashville, New Orleans, and countless other southern cities, towns, and country hamlets, preachers and the churchpeople they directed...
8. Black Church Leaders and Politics in the Civil War
The African American clergy’s antislavery efforts constituted its most important role during the Civil War.1 While historians have acknowledged the centrality of black preachers in the struggle for freedom, however, they have sometimes failed to note the nuances and variants of wartime African American clerical leadership.2 This stems from the scholarly tendency to accentuate the immediate impact that emancipation...
The end of the Civil War did not bring an end to all of the rhetorical battles between church members of common denominations or between preachers and their parishioners. Even those traditions that achieved a comparably amicable division, as was true of Episcopalianism, did not realize postwar reunion painlessly. Protestant Episcopals, overwhelmingly...
Page Count: 320
Publication Year: 2013
OCLC Number: 841229166
MUSE Marc Record: Download for The Politics of Faith during the Civil War