The Anglo-American Legacy of Covenant Theology
Publication Year: 2010
Published by: University of Missouri Press
Title Page, Copyright
In 1939 and 1953, Perry Miller published the two volumes of his seminal work on Puritanism, The New England Mind. They became landmarks of scholarship and captivated readers with a powerful and humane narrative of theological ideas moving an entire society in fascinating and consequential directions. The ideas of Reformed Protestants continue to interest scholars. Part...
An author is a debtor. In the course of his work he has drawn on the time, trust, and resources of others. He has relied on the talents of those who have gone before him, and he owes something to those who will use his work after it is published. The details of these obligations are not spelled out in contracts. They are implicit covenants that resemble the subject of this book. I hope those...
1. Introduction: Returning to Political Theology
This is a study of a particular political theology and its variants, a tradition found among Reformed Protestants over three centuries and one that substantially changed the direction of political thinking in the modern world. “Political theology” is a term requiring some explanation, together with a brief defense of its use instead of the term “civil religion.”1 Noting the difference...
2. Defending Political Theology
The brief defense of political theology in the last chapter does not imply that this study is a defense of all political theology. Important distinctions must be made. All theology, by definition, concerns God; thus any text that concerns God can be broadly categorized as a theological text. Some theological texts are explicit in their dependence upon “revealed” sources. The Bible, for example, claims to...
3. The Biblical Background to Covenanting
The Bible is the main source for Western political theology. It is the most influential text in Anglo-American political thought and probably presents the oldest political constitution in the historical record.1 But the Bible is significant not because it prescribes a particular type of regime.2 Regime classification is a Greek and Roman project.3 It is the relational attributes of biblical religion that make it...
4. Founding Covenant Theologies: Bullinger and Calvin
Two theologians whose ideas were most influential for the initial direction of Anglo-American political theology were Jean (John) Calvin (1509–1564) and Heinrich (Henry) Bullinger (1504–1575). Their legacies are the reformations of Geneva and Zurich, respectively, and represent differing but complementary approaches to political theology within the covenant model....
5. Regime, Discipline, and Resistance: The Covenant and the Civil Magistrate
The political implications of Bullinger’s and Calvin’s theologies now deserve a more intentional analysis. Their legacies remain in a state of both competition and cooperation throughout the Anglo-American experience. Only by continuing to view them side-by-side can one fully appreciate the development of the Reformed Protestant inheritance for politics....
6. The Legacies of Geneva and Zurich in England and Scotland
The Anglo-American trajectory of Reformed political theology begins in Zurich and Geneva in the sixteenth century. These legacies then combined with new elements of English and Reformed Protestantism in the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries. Reformed political theology developed further during both the crucible of war in Britain during the mid–sixteenth century and...
7. Covenant, Revolution, War, and Eschatology
Continuing the historical narrative of covenant theology’s legacy in Britain, we come now to the “Wars of the Three Kingdoms.”1 Reformed theology and covenants played a prominent political role in the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries in England and Scotland. The most obvious contribution of Reformed political theology was to provide justification for revolution...
8. Reaching Limits: The Covenant in America
New England was settled by Protestants in the Reformed tradition. Most of them were Puritans holding largely to the Congregational style of church polity. Like the English Independents, Congregationalists believed in local selfrule by churches independent of a larger church hierarchy, presbytery, or bishops. Presbyterians began arriving as early as 1634. Cotton Mather reported at...
9. Natural Law and Natural Right in Reformed Political Theology
Having summarized the historical theory and practice of Reformed political theology over three centuries, it now becomes appropriate to situate the Reformed Protestants within the mainstream of political theory. It is important to determine how they used natural law and natural right in their thinking, and how they understood related arguments from reason and from nature. Briefly...
10. The Reformation in Retrospect
Reformed Protestant Hebraism, emphasizing the Old Testament patriarchs, circumcision, and covenants, was a means of recasting the Christian’s relationship with God. Calvin and Bullinger and other sixteenth-century reformers were looking at the same biblical text as their Roman Catholic predecessors, but their construction of a new theological continuity stretching back to the Hebrew...
11. Contemporary Perspectives on Covenanting
Several modern scholars of political theory have studied the prospects of covenants for contemporary politics. Eric Voegelin argued the covenant to be an important but precarious political symbol. Daniel Elazar argued for the continuing relevance of political covenanting. David Novak has taken the most exclusive view of covenanting, leading to the most narrow contemporary application for...
12. Lessons for Religion and Politics Today
For Voegelin, the covenant is a symbol that both reveals the tension inherent in human existence and transcends political or moral appropriation. For Elazar, the covenant is a peerless and flexible device underlying modern constitutionalism, federalism, and social contracts. For Novak, the covenant appears as both symbol and device only for communities sharing a revelatory tradition...
Page Count: 264
Publication Year: 2010
MUSE Marc Record: Download for Politics Reformed