"BEOWULF,LAW, AND THEMAKING OF GERMANIC ANTIQUITY"
Publication Year: 2011
Published by: West Virginia University Press
Series: WV MEDIEVEAL EUROPEAN STUDIES
Title Page, Copyright, Series Information
This study considers the influence of nineteenth-century legal historians on the editing and interpretation of Beowulf. It is both a contribution to the study of Anglo-Saxonism and an attempt to historicize the assumptions that Beowulf criticism habitually employs regarding the legal setting of the poem. Since a number of the doctrines explored within this study have undergone no critical analysis for several decades, I have occasionally not been able to avoid offering new arguments regarding the nature of Germanic legal practices that have significant implications for how we read Beowulf. This is especially the case in my...
Introduction: “The Forests Of Germany”: Legal History and the Inheritance of Philology
The last two decades have seen a proliferation of books and articles concerned with the historical and cultural background of contemporary Old English studies. Indeed, the study of Anglo-Saxonism has reached such a degree of popularity that one could be forgiven for thinking that the desire to historicize the discipline is a new development. Of course it is not: two biographies of John Mitchell Kemble have been available to scholars for several decades, as have Berkhout and Gatch’s classic anthology of essays on the origins of Anglo-Saxon scholarship and Hans Aarsleff’s invaluable history of eighteenth- and...
Jakob Grimm, Legal Formalism and the Editing of Beowulf
“Public Land,” Germanic Egalitarianism, and Nineteenth-century Philology
In Beowulf we are told that, upon the completion of Heorot, King Hrothgar intended to distribute to young and old all that God had given him with two exceptions: he could not give the “folk-share” (folcscare) and the lives of men (feorum gumena).1 This passage has vexed Beowulf scholarship since the beginning of modern textual editing in the nineteenth century. Beowulf l. 73 seems to have no parallels in Old English prose or verse, and a number of scholars have assumed the line to be defective...
The Ecstasy of Vengeance: Nineteenth-century Germanism and the Finn Episode
Few portions of Beowulf have elicited a greater quantity of critical comment than the digression known as the “Finn Episode,” a brief narrative of the battle between Hengest and Finn that is recited upon Beowulf’s defeat of Grendel. The episode contains some of the most troublesome cruces of the poem and a number of passages that are hopelessly obscure without recourse to emendation.1 Given its singular difficulties, it is surprising that this digression is routinely used in scholarship as evidence by which to assess attitudes toward the feud in Anglo- Saxon England. Particularly in the last century, considerable...
Feohleas Gefeoht: Accidental Homicide and the Hrethel Episode
Before embarking on his fight with the dragon, Beowulf pauses to remember in a lengthy speech the many guðræsa[s] (“war-onsets”) he had experienced in his youth.1 The first among them is no fight at all, but an accidental slaying he witnessed while fostered in the household of king Hrethel: the killing of Herebeald by his brother Hæthcyn, most likely in a hunting accident. Though there is no question according to Beowulf that the fatal arrow was shot at Herebeald unintentionally, Beowulf’s statement that Hæthcyn “prepared a murder-bed” (morþorbed strêd) for Herebeald suggests his reluctance to accept...
Conclusions: Law and the Archaism of Beowulf
I would like to conclude this study with some remarks concerning the “archaism” of Beowulf, an issue that should be distinguished from the problem of the poem’s date. I believe that it is in discussions of the degree to which Beowulf exemplifies “archaic” attitudes characteristic of early Germanic-speaking peoples that we encounter one of the most persistent legacies of nineteenth-century legal-historical scholarship—one whose relevance to the state of present-day scholarship on Old English is considerable...
Page Count: 183
Publication Year: 2011
Edition: 1st ed.
Series Title: WV MEDIEVEAL EUROPEAN STUDIES
Series Editor Byline: John Smith, Will Wordsworth See more Books in this Series
MUSE Marc Record: Download for ANCIENT PRIVILEGES