How Stories Can Shape Clinical Practice
Publication Year: 2011
Published by: The Johns Hopkins University Press
Psychiatrists listen to stories more than anything else they do.1 Their very first questions—“What brings you here?” and “What seems to be the problem?”— are open-ended invitations to a story. Patients respond to these invitations by telling psychiatrists about their life and their troubles. They give narratives of when their difficulties began, what they believe to have caused them, and what kinds of problem solving they have...
1. Listening to Chekhov
Despite the seriousness of what we call mental illness in contemporary times— both its pervasive incidence and the extensive suffering it causes— this is an era that struggles with how to understand the multiple interpretations of psychic suffering and psychic difference. Most psychiatric discourse embraces a biological model that articulates mental illness as a medical disease involving neurological pathology. This model...
2. Narrative Medicine
Many in psychiatry may fear that a turn to narrative will risk alienating their hard-nosed medical cousins. They may think to themselves, “With the recent decade of the brain, the growth in ‘hard’ science research, and the explosion of pharmacological interventions, we are finally starting to get some respect from our medical colleagues. We are no longer a ‘soft’ specialty, one that is not ‘really medicine.’ We can hold...
3. Narrative Approaches to Psychotherapy
Leading thinkers in psychotherapy, what we could consider the “other side” of psychiatry, have recently taken a narrative turn. And just as we had to tell a story to understand the rise of narrative medicine, we must also tell a story to understand the emergence of narrative approaches to psychotherapy. The story of psychotherapy I will tell, like many others before me, begins in the late nineteenth century with...
4. Narrative Psychiatry
Having reviewed the emergence of narrative medicine and narrative approaches to psychotherapy integration, we are now in a position to draw out the implications for narrative psychiatry. The history of psychiatry has led to its own conceptual knots and practical predicaments. As for narrative medicine and narrative psychotherapy integration, the turn to narrative provides a way out of these difficulties. This...
5. Mrs. Dutta and the Literary Case
Narrative psychiatry insights become clearer when we use them to consider case examples. Through case examples, narrative theory becomes concrete and the relevance of narrative psychiatry is brought vividly to life. Case examples also demonstrate much of the wisdom of narrative theory because they tell a story about a person and that story is necessarily shaped by the tools of narrative I have discussed: plot, ...
6. Mainstream Stories I: BIOPSYCHIATRY, COGNITIVE BEHAVIORAL THERAPY, AND PSYCHOANALYSIS
In the last chapter, I asked readers to imagine Mrs. Dutta, the main character from Chitra Divakaruni’s “Mrs. Dutta Writes a Letter,” as a potential psychiatric client. Divakaruni carefully and beautifully describes how Mrs. Dutta becomes increasingly sad and hopeless as she realizes the impossibilities of her current living situation. I asked readers to imagine that Mrs. Dutta comes to see a psychiatrist at this time of crisis and that her...
7. Mainstream Stories II: INTERPERSONAL THERAPY, FAMILY THERAPY, AND HUMANISTIC THERAPY
The model of suffering adopted by interpersonal psychotherapy makes an important shift from the models we have discussed thus far. Interpersonal psychotherapy moves the focus from the individual person to the person’s interpersonal context. The founder of interpersonal psychotherapy, Gerald Klerman, associates the emergence of this approach with the pioneering work Harry Stack Sullivan (Klerman, Weissman, Rounsaville, and Chevron 1984, 6). The epigraph to Klerman and his associate’s first...
8. Alternative Stories: SPIRITUAL THERAPY, EXPRESSIVE THERAPY, AND CULTURAL, POLITICAL, AND FEMINIST THERAPIES
Mainstream clinical stories only begin to help us imagine alternatives for Mrs. Dutta. This means that narrative psychiatry must look to additional clinical stories for important narrative resources. There are a host of additional approaches on the margins of what we could call “clinical” and many more that move beyond the clinics all together. As a group, I refer to these additional possibilities as “alternative stories,” and...
9. Doing Narrative Psychiatry
How can practicing clinicians make sense of the last three chapters? For many psychiatrists there will be something deeply disquieting and disorienting about the exercise. Many psychiatrists will have internalized their training in science, data, and clinical trials and will be distant from the worlds of literature, narrative, and theories of meaning. Seeing Mrs. Dutta’s story interpreted in vastly different ways can go...
10. Critical Reflections
The evidence of Mrs. Dutta’s story and the efforts of bioethics and the recovery movement make a compelling case for adopting narrative approaches, but there are also many objections to putting narrative psychiatry into wider practice. It helps to work through these objections because responding to critics moves us beyond theory and creates space to consider more practical concerns. In addition, working through...
Appendix: “Mrs. Dutta Writes a Letter,”
Page Count: 240
Publication Year: 2011
OCLC Number: 794700380
MUSE Marc Record: Download for Narrative Psychiatry