Archaeology, Cultural Heritage, and the Antiquities Trade
Publication Year: 2006
Published by: University Press of Florida
There is an international heritage crisis: archaeological sites are being looted at an increasing rate and the illicit antiquities trade is escalating throughout the world. Looting and the antiquities trade severely affect those who wish to know the social history...
Preface and Acknowledgments
The looting of archaeological sites and the resultant loss of knowledge is fact. This volume provides a review of the current issues surrounding the destruction of archaeological sites and the illicit trade in antiquities. The concerns surrounding access to and preservation of archaeological heritage are underscored by graphic examples of...
There is a booming international trade in antiquities of all kinds, and from all countries of the world. Many of these antiquities are removed destructively from archaeological sites, monuments, or cultural institutions, illegally exported from their countries of origin, and converted into legal commodities through a series of commercial...
1. Protecting Cultural Heritage in Conflict
The 1954 Hague Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict and its associated Protocols are among the great humanitarian legal instruments, together with the Geneva Conventions and those on Genocide and Torture, that were developed in the twentieth century in order to try to minimize the inhumanity...
2. The U.S. Legal Response to the Protection of the World Cultural Heritage
The worldwide looting of archaeological sites and ancient monuments has grown in the past two decades to alarming proportions (Atwood 2004). Every time an object is ruthlessly extracted from the ground and separated from its context—rather than being scientifically excavated—invaluable historical knowledge is irreparably...
3. Recent Developments in the Legal Protection of Cultural Heritage
The opening years of the twenty-first century have seen considerable progress in the use of the legal system to combat the looting and destruction of archaeological sites, while at the same time illuminating significant deficiencies in the ability of both the international and national legal regimes to respond effectively to cultural heritage crises...
4. Convicted Dealers: What We Can Learn
Over the past few years no fewer than four dealers in antiquities have appeared in court, in three countries, charged with offenses relating to the illegal excavation and/or illegal export and/or import of antiquities. All of them have been convicted of criminal offences, three have been jailed, and one is appealing the guilty verdict and sentence...
5. St. Lawrence Island's Legal Market in Archaeological Goods
We tend to characterize all undocumented digging as illicit looting, but sometimes it can be a legitimate activity and part of a legal trade in antiquities. In either case, ethnographic studies of these activities have much to offer archaeologists and others who have concerns about conserving the archaeological record in situ. In 1995 I began exploring...
6. A Model Investigative Protocol for looting and Anti-Looting Educational Program
Archaeologists combat looting—the illegal removal of archaeological resources— through expert assistance in legal prosecutions and public education. Expert assistance in combating international looting relies on protocols that incorporate a universal code of archaeological ethics. In many countries, criminal investigations and prosecutions...
7. The Plunder of the Ulua Valley, Honduras, and a Market Analysis for Its Antiquities
By 1941 Doris Stone (1941) had documented at least several hundred mounds at the site of Travesía in the Lower Ulúa Valley. Today approximately twentyfive mounds remain, most riddled with large trenches. These looters’ pits make it impossible to walk comfortably...
8. Looting Lydia: The Destruction of an Archaeological Landscape in Western Turkey
A fertile and resource-rich region of western Turkey, Lydia was once the domain of an independent dynasty of famously rich kings whose capital was Sardis (map 8.1). These kings and their elite successors left remnants of their greatness throughout the region. Some such remains were plundered as long ago as Roman times and others are still being...
9. From the Ground to the Buyer: A Market Analysis of the Trade in Illegal Antiquities
Every day in shops, on the Internet, and in auction houses, people purchase archaeological artifacts. On Web sites such as eBay an individual can buy anything from a Folsom point to a Roman silver figure of Hermes to an Aztec water goddess wall plaque, paying from U.S. $2.99 to $29,000.1 Archaeological material is readily available in...
10. The Plunder of iraq's Archaeological Heritage, 1991-2005, and the London Antiquities Trade
Before the 1991 Gulf War, Iraq’s archaeological heritage was under the supervision and protection of a large, well-organized and professional Department of Antiquities and remained relatively free from theft and vandalism (Gibson 1997). In the aftermath of that war, however, as the country descended into chaos, between 1991...
11. Afghanistan's Cultural heritage: An Exceptional Case?
The fate of Afghanistan’s cultural heritage since 1993 has been quite extraordinary. Not only has the country been deprived of a large part of its movable heritage, but also its most significant immovable heritage has fallen victim to an act of willful destruction. This unfortunate fate provides a starting point for many archaeological, legal...
12. Illicit Trafficking and Trade in Indian Antiquities: Renewed Efforts to Save and Preserve India's Heritage
Article 49 of the Constitution of India states: “It shall be the obligation of the State to protect every monument or place or object of artistic or historic interest, declared by or under law made by Parliament to be of national importance, from spoliation, disfigurement, destruction, removal, disposal or export, as the case may be.” Article 51A states...
13. Museum Acquisitions: Responsibilities for the Illicit Traffic in Antiquites
The disaster that befell the Iraqi National Museum immediately after the coalition occupation of Baghdad in 2003 reminds us again of the widespread practice of looting, both adventitious and organized, both of existing museum collections and of still unexcavated areas of archaeological sites. The looters are financed, whether before...
14. Structural Complexity and Social Conflice in Managing the Past at Copan, Honduras
In the field of cultural patrimony protection, academics and practitioners face increasing challenges in developing long-term strategies for the care of archaeological sites. Now more than ever, a growing number of audiences find relevance in the past: descendant...
15. Supporting and Promoting the Idea of a Shared Cultural Patrimony
The concept of the interconnectedness of humanity whereby all humans share a deep and complex cultural heritage is important in archaeology, although it is not necessarily shared by people outside the discipline. The diverse stakeholders in cultural heritage take various...
16. Artifacts and Emotion
The discussion surrounding the trade in antiquities is heated and highly politicized. That much is plain to anyone who ventures into this field. It is also obvious that the arguments are polarized with entrenched positions that appear to be intractable. And yet it is clear that destruction of archaeological sites and monuments, which...
17. Conclusion: The Social and Cultural Contexts of Collecting
The themes expressed in most chapters of this book are remarkably similar: the pillage of archaeological sites and cultural institutions continues, and the antiquities market thrives. On the ground, data from field surveys clearly point to a growing problem of plunder, and the type of material appearing on the open art market correlates...
Appendix A. Law Enforcement Responsibilities Checklist
Appendix B. Archaeologist's Responsibilities Checklist
Appendix C. A Practical Exercise in Criminal Investigation
Page Count: 368
Illustrations: 28 b&w illustrations, 3 tables, 5 maps
Publication Year: 2006
OCLC Number: 735602620
MUSE Marc Record: Download for Archaeology, Cultural Heritage, and the Antiquities Trade