The Shame of Medicine
Publication Year: 2011
Published by: Syracuse University Press
Title Page, Copyright
For the person who takes his own life, suicide is, prima facie, a solution. Nevertheless, we think, and are enjoined to think, that suicide is a problem, specifically a mental health or psychiatric problem. This is a novel idea and a very odd one. The idea of “suicide prevention” is odder still....
I owe a very special debt to Anthony Stadlen for his generous and invaluable assistance. I thank also Mira de Vries; Keith Hoeller; Roger Yanow; my son-in-law, Steve Peters; and my brother, George, for reading the manuscript and their helpful suggestions...
Birth and death are biological events, the consequences of antecedent actions or occurrences. In the animal world, both events are pure happenings, outside the scope of the organism’s understanding or influence. The development of human consciousness and intelligence creates conditions that enable humans to bring...
1. Suicide Prohibition
Diseases are prevented. Crimes are prohibited. Our systematic mislabeling of suicide prohibition as suicide prevention is incontrovertible evidence of linguistic distortion in the service of medical- statist ideology. The essay “Youth Suicide” on the Web site of...
2. The Suicide Prohibition Agent
Medicine is often called a “helping profession.” On the commonly held understanding that “help” means aiding an individual advance his own interests, as he sees them, helping a person who wants to kill himself would be like helping a person to read,...
3. The Marriage of Asclepius and Atropos
In Greek mythology, Asclepius is the god of healing, Atropos the goddess of dying. In politicized American medicine, their functions are merged. In 2003, the US Department of Health and Human Services announced its sponsorship of “an array of...
4. Separation: Emigration, Secession, Suicide
Why do people kill themselves? Because they are mentally ill. Death from suicide, experts on mental health insist and the press repeats, is the result of mental illness, just as death from cancer is the result of bodily illness.1 This is nonsense—mindless belief in a literalized...
5. The Shame of Medicine
Throughout most of history, medical care was a personal service provided by physicians to individuals who sought their help. The recipient-patient selected the individual whose assistance he desired and paid for the service he received. By paying for the...
In “The Myth of Sisyphus” (1942), Albert Camus famously declares, “There is but one truly serious philosophical problem, and that is suicide.”1 Seventy years later, everyone knows that suicide is a psychiatric emergency, not a philosophical problem....
Appendix: “On Suicide” by David Hume
The “principle of self-ownership”—one of the bedrock premises of modern libertarianism—was fully articulated by the Scottish philosopher David Hume. His essay “On Suicide” is a pioneering defense of our “right” to end our own lives. Composed probably in 1755, published...
Page Count: 160
Publication Year: 2011
OCLC Number: 785782969
MUSE Marc Record: Download for Suicide Prohibition