The Birth of the Past
Publication Year: 2011
Published by: The Johns Hopkins University Press
Americans know that history matters. Jurists and politicians, pundits and bloggers invoke history to support their visions of the form of government we should live under and the sort of wars we should wage, the schools and universities we should build and support and the ways in which we should exploit our natural resources. But as Jill Lepore and others have pointed out, most of the history...
The intuition that inspired this book occurred to me more than thirty years ago, while I was crossing a quadrangle at the University of Chicago, trudging along in my customary state of graduate-student befuddlement. Somewhere around Botany Pond I experienced a brief moment of intellectual clarity, the memory of which has stayed with me ever since. I had been musing about the Renaissance “attitude toward the past”— the ever-elusive subject of my dissertation— when I suddenly...
Introduction: The Past Defined
The title of this book invites reflection, for it posits the birth of something forever and always dead. To explain away this paradox, one might presume I am referring to the birth of what will become the past; but if I were, I would have entitled the book “The Birth of the Present”— a questionable project for a historian. One might ...
Part One. Antiquity
Flatland. Arguably the greatest of all historians, Thucydides remains at best intensely difficult for modern readers and at worst utterly boring. In part the reason for his inaccessibility lies in his deadpan description of even the most horrific events, embroiling a complex cast of characters— aloof statesmen, pandering demagogues, egocentric rogues, decent fools— depicted with the severest economy of expression. The pulse of the narrative barely quickens as Spartans slaughter the courageous...
Part Two. Christianity
Can’t Get Here from There. Between antiquity’s profusion of pasts and modernity’s single, unitary past lies an unbridgeable divide, though we fail to see it as such. Looking back from our side of the divide, we naturally assume that earlier notions contribute to later ones, that some feature or features of classical thought evolved, perhaps in combination with other elements, to produce what we regard as “the” past. We thus have convenient recourse to the commonplace about Western civilization as the coming together of two traditions— the Greco-Roman and the Judeo-Christian—whose mixture combined...
Part Three. Renaissance
The Living Past. An icon of High Renaissance art, Raphael’s School of Athens adorns a room in the Vatican’s papal apartments, the Stanza della Segnatura, or “Room of the Segnatura,” so named for the papal tribunal that originally met there. By the time Raphael began decorating this room around 1508, it was intended to house Pope Julius II’s library and serve as his personal study. The pope commissioned from...
Part Four. Enlightenment
In Montaigne’s rambling essay “Of Coaches,” which (among other topics) entails a famous denunciation of Spanish cruelties in the New World, we find a remarkable estimation of the Aztecs and their encounter with Cortés and his conquistadors. Montaigne begins with a relatively short sentence that frames Aztec virtue in classical and Europe an terms, but this estimation gives way—in the long-exhaled...
Epilogue: The Past Historicized
The Spirit of the Laws heralds a comparative tendency in French Enlightenment thought subsequently epitomized by Voltaire’s sweeping history of civilization, the Essai sur l’histoire générale et sur les moeurs et l’esprit des nations (1756), translated as the Essay on Manners. An immense labor for even so prolific an author, the seven-volume Essay recasts the story of universal history—which had previously been shaped around the biblical account of humanity—in a comparative...
Page Count: 336
Publication Year: 2011
OCLC Number: 794700408
MUSE Marc Record: Download for The Birth of the Past