In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:

Reviewed by:
  • A Culture's Catalyst: Historical Encounters with Peyote and the Native American Church in Canada by Fannie Kahan
  • Alexander Dawson
Fannie Kahan. A Culture's Catalyst: Historical Encounters with Peyote and the Native American Church in Canada.. ed. Erika Dyck. University of Manitoba Press. xiv, 134. $24.95

Historians find all sorts of interesting things in the archives, including reams of gossipy correspondence, doodled to-do lists, and the occasional gem. This seems to be what Erika Dyck, a historian at the University of Saskatchewan, decided she had encountered when she came across Fannie Kahan's unpublished manuscript in the papers of Abram Hoffer. Written more than a half-century ago as an account of peyotism on the Canadian Prairies, A Culture's Catalyst languished without a publisher in spite of Kahan's impressive credentials as a journalist. Its failure to see the light of day leaves one with some significant questions. Was it simply no good? Was it ahead of its time? What other reasons might explain the text's failure to find a publisher? More than this, the reader is left to wonder how we might approach the text in the early twenty-first century. Do we read it as a long lost, but significant, work of scholarship? Or is it a curiosity, an artefact of the 1950s that speaks mainly to the peculiarities of its time?

Dyck, whose credentials as a historian of Canadian psychedelia are impeccable, thinks it needs to be read as a little bit of both. She seized on the text because of its ethnographic richness – we have here a series of chapters by Kahan as well as articles by Humphry Osmond, Duncan Blewett, Teodoro Weckowicz, and Abram Hoffer, which together paint a deeply sympathetic picture of Indigenous peyotism on the Canadian Prairies. Reading like a mix of long-form journalism, anthropology, and psychology, the articles collectively make a compelling case for the Native American Church of Canada, which was then under pressure from the Canadian state. Many Canadians viewed the peyote religion as a mere cover for the use of dangerous drugs, and peyote was restricted by federal policies that required users to acquire it through a prescription. This text sought to reshape the public narrative about this practice as well as offering a sharp critique of Federal Indian policy.

Kahan's articles, though clearly of her time, are also shocking for their prescience. She writes with an angry voice, attacking the virulent racism of Canadian government policy, its combination of foolishness and malice. We see the seeds of a much later critique of the residential schools, though here it is mostly a dark tail of authoritarianism and loss and not so much ethnocide and abuse. Indeed, her narrative is so at odds with nationalist narratives of the day that it seems unsurprising that the book languished.

Osmond's "Night in the Tipi" turns the narrative more specifically to the peyote ceremony, brilliantly capturing a moment in which a certain Orientalist approach to Native Americans and scientific curiosity played [End Page 305] out in a highly unusual context. We see the Native American Church of Canada in an incipient phase – still fairly new, reliant on Church members from south of the border both for learning and for peyote itself. Curiously, even though Osmond and his compatriots know that this is relatively new to their hosts, they treat it as an ancient secret that divides the two groups in the ceremony. Osmond and Weyburn, of course, represent their own fascinating story (which is the subject of Dyck's excellent earlier work), but here we see Osmond falling into a fairly unsurprising romance of Indigenous alterity. In this, he reinforces a narrative that places Indigenous peoples in a static and ancient past and reserves modernity for his clinic at Weyburn.

The other articles in the collection pick up on these themes. Blewett treats peyotism as a reaction to colonialism, a form of salvation from the ravages caused by Indigenous subjugation to white rule, a means of "finding some meaning in life." Weckowicz explores Jungian archetypes in Peyote ceremonies, completing the Western taxonomic project by making peyotism legible as psychological practice related to a...

pdf

Share