The title and the author's own remarks in the opening chapters suggest that this book will deal with fundamental and determining issues regarding the role of political Islam in Indonesia over the past century. Chiara Formichi claims that her study
is a historical investigation of the interaction between Islamic groups and government institutions in Indonesia from the late 1910s to today. This effort is aimed at affirming the religious foundations of Kartosuwiryo's Darul Islam and shedding light on the failure of political Islam in the 1950s … and again in the 2000s.(p. 8)
Her book is indeed a very good study of the influential Islamist leader Kartosuwiryo, but it falls short as an account of the broader struggle of political Islam in Indonesia.
S.M. Kartosuwiryo was a charismatic leading figure in the early twentieth-century Islamic movement Sarekat Islam and later, from the mid-1940s, in the Masyumi political party. His uncompromising views on non-cooperation with Dutch colonial authorities made him a controversial and polarizing figure in both organizations. In the late 1940s he was pivotal in the formation of the Darul Islam movement in West Java, which objected to the non-Islamic nature of the Indonesian republic's 1945 Constitution and to its central government's willingness to negotiate with the returning Dutch. In 1949, Darul Islam declared the establishment of an Islamic State in Indonesia, with Kartosuwiryo as imam and commander-in-chief. The resulting rebellion spread to four other provinces and became the most bloody and intractable of the many regional conflicts that beset the country during the 1950s and early 1960s. Kartosuwiryo was captured and executed for treason by the Indonesian state in 1962. [End Page 427]
The greatest strength of Formichi's study is her careful investigation of Kartosuwiryo's life and thought. There have been numerous studies of Kartosuwiryo and published versions of his writings, but none has displayed Formichi's depth of research. She examines a large number of primary documents to explore the main elements of Kartosuwiryo's thinking and how it changed over time. She is particularly interested in the role of religion and in the ways in which Kartosuwiryo drew on influences from abroad, especially those of pan-Islamism and the emerging Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt. She challenges other scholars, such as van Dijk and Jackson, who have downplayed the Darul Islam leader's Islamic motivations and expertise.
Formichi's analysis of Kartosuwiryo's writings is insightful. She investigates the nuances in her subject's beliefs and intellectualism, and seeks to explain the many apparent contradictions in his thought. He was, on one hand, mystically inclined, drawing criticism from Sareket Islam colleagues for his immersion in Sufism. On the other hand, he was a hard-nosed, ideologically fervent, Islamic politician. The two best sections of the text are those dealing with Kartosuwiryo's activism in the 1930s and the formative years of Darul Islam in the late 1940s and early 1950s.
This book is a sympathetic treatment of Kartosuwiryo. Formichi is at pains to explain her subject's views and to rationalize the many twists and turns in his thinking. But sometimes she seems too intent on casting his desultory approach in an intellectually credible light rather than to consider the possibility that his use of Islamic precepts was opportunistic or instrumental. The discussion of Kartosuwiryo's shifting definitions of jihad (pp. 105–6) is but one example of this issue.
Formichi's argument about the centrality of Islam to any explanation of Kartosuwiryo's actions has much value, but she is inclined to assert her points rather than to argue them systematically. For instance, although she is critical of van Dijk's emphasis on non-religious factors in accounting for Kartosuwirjo's behaviour, she does not [End Page 428] discuss her points of contention one by one in order to establish the superiority of her position. Her overlooking Holk Dengel's detailed study on Kartosuwiryo and Darul Islam is also surprising.
Perhaps the most serious shortcoming of...