In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:

Reviews 77 Crossing the River. Edited byKristjana Gunnars. (Manitoba: Turnstone Press, 1988. 213 pp., $12.95.) This collection of essays in tribute to Margaret Laurence’sgenius provides ample indication of why she is revered as the “founding Mother of Canadian literature.” Beyond having given eloquent voice to the Manitoba prairie in her “Manawaka” series, she speaks for the tribes of all humankind—women, the old, and the oppressed everywhere. Anyone reading these essays will feel com­ pelled to know Laurence’s work better, and we in the American West have some stretching to do in that regard. As these essays make clear, Laurence was a citizen of the world—an author of the first rank, compared with Tolstoy, Cather, and Faulkner because of the rich fictionalized world she creates and the ultimate truths she tells. This book exhibits fine and insightful criticism— criticism written with unusual affection and respect. HELEN BEACH CANNON Utah State University A Ruth Suckow Omnibus. By Ruth Suckow (Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 1988. 310 pages, $9.95.) Ruth Suckow’s reputation rests principally on the fiction she produced in the 1920s and early 1930s. Although she continued to write almost until her death in 1960, Suckow went into a partial eclipse during the last twenty-five years of her life. Recently, however, her work seems to have experienced some­ thing of a revival. In 1966 this journal published an article on her late collec­ tion Some Others and Myself, and now the University of Iowa Press has issued A Ruth Suckow Omnibus, containing ten stories, some previously uncollected, and a short novel. The Suckow trademark is evident in all these pieces. As in her betterknown novels and short-story collections, she avoids melodrama or even intense expressions of emotion, preferring to achieve her objectives through under­ statement. These typically low-key treatments of small-town life reflect the usual Suckow themes: the woman whom life passes by, the conflict between elderly parents and their adult children, the persistent snobbishness in sup­ posedly classless midwestern towns, the joys and sorrows of childhood. As in most such collections, the harvest in the volume is uneven. Despite Clarence Andrews’mildly disparaging remarks about it in his generally excel­ lent introduction, “Susan and the Doctor” isoneof Suckow’sbestperformances, as its placement at the beginning of the book may suggest. The second story, “Home-coming,” is also a noteworthy achievement, with its recognition by the central character that life, though it might have been different, has to be lived 78 Western American Literature as it is. On the other hand, the novel, “A Part of the Institution,” tries to compress too many years into too few pages, and the stories about childhood strike this reader as trivial. Except for “Visiting,” set in Colorado, the Midwest is the locale of all these stories. Even in “Visiting” the West figures only as an alien environment, at most an escape from a way of life rejected as repressive and thwarting. Suckow will probably never regain the stature she enjoyed when Mencken called her “the most remarkable woman . . . writing stories in the republic,” but it is good to see more of her work back in print. ROY W. MEYER Mankato State University William Everson: The Life of BrotherAntoninus. ByLee Bartlett. (New York: New Directions, 1988. 272 pages, $25.95.) “The biographer is a presence in life-writing,” Leon Edel has said, “in charge of handling the material, establishing order, explaining and analyzing the ambiguities and anomalies. Biography is dull if it’s just dates and facts: it has for too long ignored the entire province of psychology and the emotions. Ultimately, there must be a sense of inwardness of human beings as well as outwardness: the ways in which . . . fantasies become plays and novels and poems....” Mindful of the above, readers will understand what I mean when I say that—beyond his thorough research into the dates and facts included in this largely anecdotal biography, and beyond his stiff prose—Lee Bartlett isn’t a presence in William Everson: The Life of Brother Antoninus. His chrono­ logically ordered presentation islock-step;he avoids even attempting to analyze or explain any of the huge...

pdf

Share