We cannot verify your location
Browse Book and Journal Content on Project MUSE
OR
The Archive, the Students, and the Emotions of a German Israeli Intellectual
In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:

The Archive, the Students, and the Emotions of a German Israeli Intellectual
Gershom Scholem. Lamentations of Youth: The Diaries of Gershom Scholem, 1913–1919. Edited and translated by Anthony David Skinner. Cambridge Mass.: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2007. Pp. 374.
Hannah Arendt and Gershom Scholem. Der Briefwechsel. Edited by Marie Luise Knott and David Heredia. Berlin: Jüdischer Verlag im Suhrkamp Verlag, 2010. Pp. 693.
Jacob Taubes. Der Preis des Messianismus: Briefe von Jacob Taubes an Gershom Scholem und andere Materialien. Edited by Elettra Stimilli. Würzburg: Könighausen and Neumann, 2006. Pp. 179.
Morton Smith and Gershom Scholem. Correspondence, 1945–1982. Edited by Guy G. Stroumsa. Leiden: Brill, 2008. Pp. xxiv + 206.

I

When the Berlin-born Jewish adolescent Gerhard Arthur Scholem decided in 1917 to change his name to Gershom Shalom, his intention was to express two major changes in his life. First, by omitting his father’s name, which was given to him as a middle name, he turned his back on the German Jewish bourgeois culture that his father represented. Second, by changing his remaining names into Hebrew names, he turned his face toward the future: toward the revival of the Jewish people and its culture, first in Berlin and later in Palestine. The meaning of the biblical forename Gershom (from the root ger, “sojourner”) was surely known to Scholem. Moses and Tsiporah named their son Gershom to mark Moses’s status as a stranger in a foreign land (Ex 2.22). This name symbolized for [End Page 415] Scholem his own journey toward what he now came to understand as home—Zion.

This mostly inner journey is described in detail in Scholem’s early German diaries, which are published in two volumes.1 In the English edition of the diaries, Anthony David Skinner compiled and translated parts of the German original, allowing the English reader a glance into the process of Gerhard’s transformation into Gershom. Skinner makes the diaries of young Scholem available to the English reader for the first time. This is an important contribution. Nonetheless, as Skinner himself states in his introduction (p. 7), this book is an abridgment of the two German volumes, which renders the reading sometimes confusing; very often this reader was compelled to return to the original in order to receive a more complete picture.

The reader of the diaries encounters a young and rather confused Jew, searching for a group to which he could belong among the many options that the German Jewish world offered around the time of the First World War. Questions of identity and the wish to belong to a social or political Jewish group of the time are a central motif throughout the book. “I am not a German Jew,” Gerhard states on October 15, 1917. “I don’t know if I ever was one, but now I speak with absolute certainty: I am not one” (Lamentations of Youth, p. 186). But with which group could young Gerhard identify, if not with German Jewry?

His first attempt at belonging, at the age of sixteen, was to Jewish Orthodoxy, but this romance lasted only the first five months of 1914. After experiencing difficulties observing Jewish law, he left the youth group of Agudat Israel. Summing up this shift in his diary, he wrote: “It wasn’t an easy decision and it caused quite a stir, but I’m now sailing full speed ahead in the direction of Martin Buber. I’ve also become a socialist” (p. 26).

Gerhard’s socialism cannot be separated from his relationship to his elder brother Werner, who was deeply involved in the movement.2 For a time, under the influence of Werner, Gerhard took part in the activities of the socialist party in Berlin. But the rivalry between Zionism and [End Page 416] Socialism alienated him. Hearing from Werner about the anti-Semitic tendencies within the Socialist Party, he came to his own conclusion in December 1914: “This is definitive proof for the correctness of Zionist teachings” (p. 45). The most significant event in Gerhard’s life during these years was undoubtedly the outbreak of World War I in the summer of...