- Becoming Cosmopolitan: On the Idea of a Japanese Response to American Philosophy
- Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society: A Quarterly Journal in American Philosophy
- Indiana University Press
- Volume 47, Number 4, Fall 2011
- p. pp. 507-523
- View Citation
Starting with Dewey's encounter of the untranslatable in a foreign culture with his disappointing experience in Japan, this paper attempts to find an alternative mode of response to the untranslatable in another strain of American philosophy: the transcendentalism of Ralph W. Emerson and Henry D. Thoreau as reinterpreted by Stanley Cavell. This is a search for a more thorough anti-foundationalist idea of cosmopolitanism than Dewey's pragmatism allows us. I conduct this reinterpretation with reference to Cavell's ordinary language philosophy and its related idea of philosophy as translation. I conclude by proposing an alternative way of thinking about cosmopolitan education: a perfectionist education that serves the idea of achieving neighborhood through immigrancy, that is, by taking a path from the inmost to the outmost.