- Sephardic Business:Early Modern Atlantic Style
It may be difficult for nonspecialists to appreciate the success of early modern Spanish and Portuguese Jews and conversos in the Atlantic world region. Some 20,000 exiled Spanish and Portuguese Jews and a [End Page 483] far greater number of conversos still in Catholic territories built up a commercial empire so triumphant that it supported communal life, sometimes lavishly, in such far-flung locations as Hamburg, London, Kingston, and Recife. Their transnational commercial success, while it lasted, comprises a doubly remarkable achievement, given, as Francesca Trivellato of Yale reminds us, that no country "would have chartered an exclusively Sephardic commercial company, nor could Sephardic merchants raise considerable capital among non-Jews to set up large-scale operations" (Familiarity of Strangers, p. 68). Sephardic Amsterdam, built up from nothing after 1595, like all of these communities, mostly by conversos who became New Jews (Yosef Kaplan's phrase), was an admired and renowned "mother city" within but a few decades. On the ocean's far side, until roughly 1800, the Sephardic communities of Suriname and Curaçao outshone every other Jewish collective in the Western hemisphere. (Interaction of these New Jews with "old" Sephardim remains a complex question.) Curaçao's Mikvé Israel new synagogue building, inaugurated in 1732, could house a congregation of 400 men and 200 women; so well off was the community that a membership contribution (finta) was introduced only in 1810. New Jews greatly helped revivify, if not reinvent in exile, the unique style of Spanish and Portuguese Judaism. Sephardic men in the post-Columbus Americas hunted manatees off the coast of the Guianas, founded colonial settlements, captained hundreds of ships (many with Jewish names), ran sugar and coffee plantations, fought in local militias before such permission was granted in Europe, and constructed western outposts of Judaism which attracted graduating rabbis from Amsterdam's Ets Haim yeshiva well into the nineteenth century. Something both exotic yet familiar exudes from the history of these "clean-shaven Jews," as they were referred to sometimes by Ashkenazim. In nearly all of their homelands, Sephardim comprised both "agents and victims of empire," in Jonathan Israel's already classic formulation.
The rich and sophisticated new works on western Sephardim and conversos here reviewed indicate that the study of conversos/Sephardim has finally transcended its tendency to exoticize and romanticize its object. (This is less true of Kritzler's Jewish Pirates of the Caribbean, to which I will return below.) These books also reflect the degree to which Jewish studies has been able to escape its provincialism and frequent fixation on identity politics, becoming more of a full participant in contemporary academic currents. The quincentennial of 1492 may have produced several new treatments of Sephardic matters and instigated further and deeper investigation, but the recent works under discussion reflect a [End Page 484] whole new level of interest and analysis, both quantitatively and qualitatively.1 Though most...