In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:

Reviewed by:
  • Les carnets du cardinal Baudrillart (26 décembre 1928-12 février 1932)
  • John Hellman
Les carnets du cardinal Baudrillart (26 décembre 1928-12 février 1932). Edited by Paul Christophe. (Paris: Les Éditions du Cerf. 2003. Pp. 1136. €65,00.)

Since 1993 Paul Christophe has published, with the Dominicans' Editions du Cerf, the texts of dozens of handwritten journals—divided into nine annotated and indexed 1000-page volumes—of Cardinal Alfred Baudrillart. The distinguished Academician freshly recorded, from August 1, 1914, the many encounters and events of his very active life. Recently made accessible in the archives of that same Institut Catholique which he directed for thirty-five years, they document its history—from the first in fine penmanship to the final sixty-fifth in a nearly illegible scrawl. Christophe, church historian at the Catholic University of Lille, had already published a monograph on French Catholics and the Popular Front, and 1939-1940 les catholiques devant la guerre (1989), which helps explain why he first published the dramatic Baudrillart notebooks from 1936, and the German occupation, rather than releasing them in chronological order. [End Page 684]

Alfred Baudrillart was born in 1859, son of a member of l'Académie des sciences morales who was editor of the Journal des Débats. Alfred entered the École Normale Supérieure at age 25 in 1878, had Jean Jaurès and Henri Bergson as classmates, and passed the agrégation in history in 1881. He entered the Oratory in 1890, founded the celebrated Dictionnaire d'histoire et de géographie ecclésiastiques, and was ordained a priest at age thirty-seven. In 1907, at fifty-one, he was named rector of l'Institut catholique and continued in that post until he died in 1942. In 1918 he was elected to the Académie française and frequented elite political, religious, and literary circles. Named cardinal in 1935, Baudrillart became something of an ambassador, visiting Spain, Portugal, French colonies in North Africa, as he became more and more anti-Communist, pro-fascist and even pro-Nazi, until his death in occupied Paris.

Contemporary Catholic prelates now leave personal journals for publication, but these Baudrillart diaries are not the revelatory, soul-searching documents of a Wojtyl/a or a Ratzinger, but rather a daily account by an observant "political animal" of the people he encountered. Self-analysis, guilt, sexuality, Jesus are all notably absent. In an earlier volume Christophe deplored the cardinal rector's blessing the Légion des volontaires de France's embracing Hitler's crusade against the atheistic Bolsheviks. The present volume is one of those which have helped Christophe appreciate the complexities of, and become less judgmental about, his subject.

We encounter Moslem native peoples (annoyingly restive), Communists (malefic Stalinist agents), French political leaders (tricky, spineless), Fascist leaders (untrustworthy but promising), his fellow religious (ignorant), the Action Française (tragically betrayed), and the deference and consideration expected by the cardinal rector (considerable). We also discover Baudrillart's enduring friendship for Pétain (unaffected by the Marshal's discernible indifference to religion), his early sympathy for the other Catholics who would take up Hitler's anti-Soviet crusade (e.g., novelist Alphonse de Chateaubriant, politician Philippe Henriot). French Catholicism, this volume reminds us, produced well-known, intelligent, French patriots who, out of understandable fear of the Stalinists, became Nazi sympathizers.

These interesting diaries are of a Catholic Party Man—dedicated to France, to Pope and Church, terribly concerned with ecclesiastical discipline and his own importance. Humorless, stuffy, and indifferent to beauty and pleasure, Baudrillart emerges as a sort of French Josemaría Escrivá de Balaguer (founder of Opus Dei, canonized in 2002). The cardinal's mentality surfaced both in the L.V.F. and the counter-insurgency efforts of the Milice, led by Catholic war hero (and SS officer) Joseph Darnand, who tortured and executed Resisters in the name of Christ the King. Baudrillart's canonization, while unthinkable when this series first went to press over a decade ago, is no longer outside of the realm of possibility.

John Hellman
McGill University
...

pdf

Share